Both can save your holiday — but they suit different ages and different kinds of trips. Here’s the honest comparison, so you know which one your family actually needs.
Short answer: A hotel kids club is a fun daytime add-on for school-age kids (roughly 4+) who want to socialise — but it runs on the club’s schedule, in one place, and often you or a partner need to stay nearby. A private nanny works for children of any age — newborn to teens — comes to you, gets to know your family and your kids, and gives you real freedom (including evenings out), because it’s one-to-one care from someone you’ve chosen, checked and can trust.
What a hotel kids club actually offers
Most resorts in Phuket, Koh Samui, Bali and beyond run a kids club: a supervised play space with games, crafts, and activities, staffed by trained carers. For the right age, it’s brilliant — kids make friends and burn energy while you get a couple of hours by the pool.
The good
- Affordable — often included in the room rate, or a small daily fee.
- Social — your child plays with other kids their age.
- No planning — drop off, walk away, come back.
The catch
- Age limits — most start at 4 years old (some from 3). Babies and toddlers usually can’t go.
- You often can’t really leave — for younger children, or at busy times, a parent is expected to stay and supervise. So it’s not always the hands-off break you hoped for.
- Group care — one carer to many children, and different staff each time; not one-to-one attention and no chance to build a bond.
- Fixed hours & place — it runs on the club’s schedule, at the club, not your room. No help in the evening.
- Varying standards — ratios and supervision differ a lot between hotels, especially around pools.
What a private holiday nanny offers
A private nanny comes to your hotel room, villa or resort and looks after your children one-to-one, for the hours you choose. She fits around your day — nap times, meal times, a lie-in, a late dinner — instead of you fitting around a club.
The good
- Works for any age — newborns and babies right through to older kids and teens. Not just for little ones.
- Gets to know your family — one familiar person who learns your kids’ names, routines and quirks, and builds a real bond with them over the trip.
- Someone you can check first — you see her profile, experience and real references and reviews before you book, so you know who’s coming.
- Total flexibility — mornings, full days, split shifts, or an evening out while the kids sleep in their own bed. The club can’t do evenings; a nanny can.
- You can actually go out — because it’s one-to-one care from someone you trust, you’re free to leave and enjoy your holiday, day or night.
- Comes to you — no packing the kids up and dropping them off.
The catch
- Costs more than a club — you’re paying for private, one-to-one care.
- You want to trust her — which is exactly why vetting, references and reviews matter (more on that below).
Kids club vs private nanny: side by side
| Hotel kids club | Private nanny | |
|---|---|---|
| Ages | ~4 and up only | Any age — newborn to teens |
| Attention | Group, rotating staff | One-to-one, same nanny |
| Gets to know your kids | No (different carers) | Yes — builds a bond |
| Can you actually leave? | Often must stay nearby | Yes — you’re free to go out |
| Evenings / date night | Usually not available | Yes |
| Flexibility | Fixed hours & location | Your hours, comes to you |
| Keeps your child’s routine | Harder | Yes |
| Cost | Cheap / included | ~$60 half day, ~$100 full day |
| Socialising with other kids | Yes | No (private) |
So which should you choose?
It’s not really either/or — it’s about your kids and your trip. Quick guide:
- You want to actually go out — an evening, a spa day, a diving trip: a private nanny, at any age. It’s the only option that reliably lets you leave, because the club is daytime-only and often needs a parent to stay.
- You have a baby or toddler (under 4): a private nanny — the club won’t take them, and little ones need one-to-one care on their own schedule.
- You have older kids or teens too: a nanny still works — she’s not just for little ones. One familiar person can look after the whole age range and bond with them over the trip.
- You want your kids to make friends and burn energy in the day: the kids club is great for that (for 4+) — many families pair it with a nanny for evenings and days out.
- Mixed-age kids (a toddler + an older child): a nanny keeps them together with one person, instead of splitting them up.
- You just want a cheap hour by the pool with older kids and you’re happy to stay nearby: the club does the job.
Plenty of families use both — the club for daytime play, a nanny for going out and for the times the club can’t cover.
Want the flexibility of a private nanny — without the worry?
Nannimoon connects traveling families with vetted, English-speaking local nannies across Thailand & Bali. Every nanny is first-aid & CPR trained, police-checked and reviewed by real parents — and every booking is backed by a 72-hour guarantee (switch nannies or get a refund if she’s not the right fit). She comes to your hotel or villa, and you can keep the same nanny for your whole stay.
Find a nanny for your trip →How to pick a nanny you can actually trust
The number-one worry with a private nanny is simple: can I trust this person with my child? That’s the whole reason to book through a vetted platform rather than a hotel’s on-call sitter or a classifieds ad. With Nannimoon, every nanny is screened — verified ID, police background check, first-aid & CPR, water and pool-safety training, and references from real families — and every profile shows genuine parent reviews. If it’s still not the right fit after she starts, the 72-hour guarantee has you covered.
Frequently asked questions
Is a kids club or a nanny better for a toddler?
For babies and toddlers, a private nanny is usually the better fit. Most kids clubs only take children from about 4, and little ones do best with one-to-one care on their own nap and feeding routine. A nanny comes to your room or villa and looks after your child one-to-one.
How much does a private holiday nanny cost in Thailand?
A vetted nanny typically costs around $60 for a half day (4 hours) and about $100 for a full day (8 hours). It’s more than a club, but you get one-to-one care, full flexibility, and every booking is backed by a 72-hour guarantee. See the full costs & booking FAQ.
Are hotel kids clubs safe?
Reputable clubs are generally safe and staffed by trained carers, but ratios and standards vary a lot between hotels. Check the minimum age, the child-to-staff ratio, and supervision near water. A vetted private nanny gives you one-to-one care you can check out yourself first.
Can I get a private nanny at my hotel or villa?
Yes — with Nannimoon you can book a vetted, English-speaking nanny who comes to your hotel or villa across Thailand and Bali, for the hours you choose, backed by a 72-hour guarantee. Browse by city, e.g. Phuket or Koh Samui.
What age can children join a hotel kids club?
Most start at around 4 years old (some from 3). Babies and toddlers under 4 usually aren’t eligible — which is why families often book a private nanny instead. And a nanny isn’t just for little ones: she can care for children of any age, from newborns to teens.
Keep reading: Hiring a nanny in Thailand — costs, vetting & booking · Do I need to tip a nanny? · Nanny in Bangkok · Nanny in Bali
0 Comment